Which is worth more: your skills or your impact? I thought this was a rhetorical question.
However, this became a topic of debate when I recently reconnected with a high school friend. Let’s call him John. For the longest time, I thought John studied “geography” and “environmental issues.” But, I realized that I got it all wrong. He has simply tried to avoid talking about or explaining his actual concentration — because he’s ashamed of it.
What does he really do? Geographical information systems (GIS). Basically, my friend can create the essence of widely used navigation systems, such as Google Maps and GPS, the maps. He can code data, layer by layer, and figure out the answers to many market questions.
- What’s the most efficient route?
- Where’s the highest concentration of people at a certain time of day?
Now that location-based technology is all the more prevalent with Foursquare, Facebook Places, Google Places…his pursued profession is absolutely relevant to the growing opportunities from all over the world.
But while I thought it was the coolest thing on earth, John simply responded, “Compared to all these friends of ours who are becoming bankers and lawyers…I feel like a loser. I don’t like talking about it… For my masters, I’m thinking about switching to the surveyor route.”
What? Why?! Are you serious?
—–
It’s not about the tasks.
“ I just map things.”
John has trouble explaining his major to others sometimes, so he just claims to be a geography major. His argument is that that is his major. For an hour, we argued about his ill-presentation of himself. If you really think about it, the tasks for whatever professions are never so exciting. In consulting, it’s research, brainstorm, create decks, and present. Investment bankers create excel spreadsheets, run the models, create decks and present. Awesome?? In the end, it’s the results that establish the glamorous reputations. John may just be creating the maps, but companies use them to manage their costs and to market to their targets more effectively. His work is enabling! We’re not out to discover the job with the most exciting tasks, are we?
—–
It’s not about the title or others’ perception.
“People would immediately recognize it if I tell them I’m a surveyor! I’d stand out.”
Sure, I understand that the perception of a surveyor is, put shortly, math genius. You are automatically categorized as smart, but…so? When he explained what surveyors do (see, he had to explain anyway), I pointed out that it’s a reactive profession. Surveyors measure geographical elements. Is this land suitable for building a skyscraper? You measure and report. I have no doubt that it requires a lot intellectual power, but you really have no control or influence over any of the results. Should your career be determined by the implied skills of your profession and how much others would appreciate them?
“I do want to do something extraordinary someday. I want to learn how to fly a plane… It’ll be my side hobby.”
My immediate question to John was, “That’s it? You’re going to settle just on that?” It confused me that the one extraordinary event of his dreams would be a hobby that’s, no offense, so selfish. Should a person be content simply because they acquired some peculiar skills?
—–
It’s about your impact.
I told John, “You can literally change the world (by mapping it differently! I kid.)!”
What’s worth more: your skills or your impact? I still believe it’s a rhetorical question. Skills are unfortunately ranked by society, but one person’s impact should never be valued more than another’s. It is an individual’s ultimate breakthrough from social constructs.
Obviously, one can argue that without some skills, a person can hardly create the impact. But, the sad realization is, skills can exist without impact. There are more people than ideal who are willing to choose skills over impact — just to ensure that they could gain others’ approval, just to feel good about themselves. It’s unfortunate.
Perhaps people should decide on their impact first, then on the needed skills. That’s what we did. It becomes too obvious then.